Amish Country Store
Hot Jalapeño Mustard – Amish Recipe, 9oz Glass Jar
Hot Jalapeño Mustard – Amish Recipe, 9oz Glass Jar
Couldn't load pickup availability
Bold Heat. Classic Amish Flavor.
Bring the heat to your next meal with our Hot Jalapeño Mustard, made from a fiery Amish recipe that’s been turning heads for generations. Packed in a convenient 9oz glass jar, this spicy mustard delivers a kick of jalapeño with just the right amount of tang.
Perfect as a dipping sauce, sandwich spread, or bold topping for burgers and brats—this mustard adds a fiery twist to any dish.
Product Highlights:
-
Traditional Amish recipe with extra jalapeño heat
-
Smooth, spicy, and full of flavor
-
9oz glass jar – ideal size for everyday use
-
No artificial preservatives
-
Great for sandwiches, meats, pretzels, and more
A little sweet, a little sharp, and a whole lot of spice—this one’s for the heat lovers.

We offer fast and free shipping on most orders over $75 and $8.99 under $75. Orders are typically processed within 1-2 business days and delivered within 3-5 business days unless specified. Expedited shipping options and all pricing options are available at checkout if applicable.
We accept returns within 30 days of purchase. Items must be unused and in original packaging. To initiate a return, please contact our customer service team. Refunds will be processed within 5-7 business days after we receive your return.
Comparison Shop
Comparing Shop Made Easy: Discover new Made in the USA farms and brands for the best products based on price and features. Build your cart or Gift Registry for Free Shipping over $75. Click the "compare" checkbox where applicable.